Tips for Color-coded Underlining of a Synopsis
- the following color code adopts the suggestions of Mark Goodacre in The Synoptic Problem: A Way Through the Maze:
| Blue |
|
words unique to Matthew |
| Purple |
|
words shared by Matthew and Mark |
| Red |
|
words unique to Mark |
| Orange |
|
words shared by Mark and Luke |
| Yellow |
|
words unique to Luke |
| Green |
|
words shared by Matthew and Luke |
| Brown (or black) |
|
words shared by all three |
Additional Tips and Guidelines
- When a string of words is in the same color: underline
them all together when the order is also identical, and underline
each word separately when the order differs.
- Not every close parallel can be placed on precisely the same
line, so read ahead before you start underlining. If it helps,
draw lines (in pencil) to connect parallel units/words/phrases
that do not appear side by side.
- You will make mistakes, so don't press too hard and be prepared to do some erasing. A common mistake is to think a word occurs in only two gospels, when you later note that it occurs in all three. In this case, using black or dark brown for the triple tradition allows you simply to line over the wrong color without erasing it.
- Some words (and, the, in, but, etc.) will occur frequently
in all columns. Look for clues in the context to indicate that
small/common words truly have a parallel function in two or more
columns.
- When the same word appears in two or three different
forms, you might want to underline the different
part of the word in a color to signal it is unique to that Gospel, and the shared part in the other, appropriate color.
- Frequently the same word will appear in entirely different forms. This can happen in Greek as well as English (e.g., "eat" and "ate"). To show both the similarity and the difference, you might try using two colors, as in the previous example.
- Sometimes you will have to make a judgment call. This is not a mindless exercise--you must keep thinking. Whatever you decide, try to be consistent.
- After you have done a pericope (paragraph), step back and
examine your work. Make notes in the margins.
Distinctive Features of Aland's Synopsis
- The scripture references at the top
of the page are in bold face only when that column contains
material in order. Correspondingly, the references are
in plain face when a passage is presented out of order.
In such cases, you can be sure that somewhere else in the book,
the same passage appears again in its proper order (with a bold
header).
- When a pericope (paragraph or unit)
appears out of order, the location of the same passage "in
order" is given in parentheses under the reference. See,
e.g., #17 on p.15: since both Matt. 14:3-4 and Mark 6:17-18 appear
out of order, we are told to go to #144 on p.133 to see the same
passages in their proper order.
- If you are studying a passage in a
particular gospel, it is usually best to examine it in its proper
sequence, which means it should appear in bold at the top of
the page.
- Small print
may indicate a remote parallel. Examine each small print passage
to determine whether or not the passage contains true, verbal
parallels. If the content is similar but not parallel, leave
it alone.
- Small print
may also help to display parallel passages that appear in reverse
order. Study the way the three temptations appear in #20 (Matt.4:1-11
and Luke 4:1-13). No need to underline the same passage twice.
- The "Index of Gospel Parallels"
and the "Index of New Testament Passages" at
the back are very helpful for finding passages.